Police

Crime mystery: Who mailed this wallet?

On July 13, 2010 Hamed Mirabdal received a manila envelope in the mail. When he opened it, he gasped.

Inside was his wallet, stolen from him four years earlier during a brutal assault in which he almost died.

There was a short note in the envelope. “Found this while gardening on San Lorenzo Avenue in North Berkeley.”

The signature was indecipherable, but the note was scribbled on stationary from Keller Williams, a national real estate chain. The address at the bottom of the paper was from an office in Pennsylvania.

Now Berkeley police have put out a public appeal for help in discovering who mailed that envelope. The wallet may be a linchpin piece of evidence in the upcoming trial of the two men accused of almost stabbing Mirabdal to death.

But police only have a few days to find the sender. The trial is scheduled to start in Alameda County Superior Court on Wednesday Sept. 1. The wallet cannot be introduced into evidence unless the prosecution can show the court who sent it, according to Det. Emily Murphy of the Berkeley police department.

Despite repeated calls to Keller Williams’ offices, Murphy has been unsuccessful in figuring out who wrote the note and mailed the package.

“We haven’t gotten anything,” said Det. Murphy. “No one has gotten back to me on the wallet. Unless I can say who found it, I can’t use the evidence in court.”

In early August, the Berkeley Police Department put up a picture of the wallet and note on its new “Who Are These Suspects?” website. Police have been posting pictures of suspected shoplifters, recovered stolen property, and other police incidents on the site for the past six months in an attempt to solicit the public’s help in solving crimes.

Mirabdal’s wallet was stolen on October 15, 2006. Police got a call around 10 pm that a man had been hurt on Poppy Lane in the Berkeley Hills.

When police arrived, they found Mirabdal, 19, barely alive. He had been stabbed more than 25 times in his neck and chest area.

A fingerprint found in Mirabdal’s car led police to Nicolas Flatbush, who was living on Parker Street in Berkeley at the time. Flatbush told police that he and a friend, Blake Mastro, had lured Mirabdal out in the car on the pretense of selling him some guns, according to court records. They intended to rob Mirabdal, said Flatbush. Flatbush told police he was the “muscle” in the operation and had been instructed by Mastro to sit behind the driver’s seat and pin Mirabdal down when Mastro mentioned the words “World Series”, according to court records.

But Flatbush was completely surprised, he said, when Mastro pulled out a knife and started stabbing Mirabdal while shouting out “So you hate Jews? So you hate Jews?

Mirabdal is of Persian descent and his family is Muslim.

After the stabbing, Mastro took papers and things from Mirabdal’s car, according to Flatbush’s statement to police.

Alameda County prosecutors apparently did not believe Flatbush’s account as they charged both him and Mastro with attempted murder and robbery. Prosecutors also added on an enhancement charge of grave bodily injury, which can add years onto a sentence.

But if Mirabdal’s wallet was found in North Berkeley, it may corroborate Flatbush’s story, since the wallet went missing from Mirabdal’s car that night, according to Det. Murphy.

Flatbush is free on $150,000 bail but Mastro has been held in jail without bail for more than three years.

The last four years have been extremely difficult for Mirabdal and his family, who live in Moraga.

The assailant punctured Mirabdal’s heart, sending blood throughout his body. His injuries triggered a massive stroke, and Mirabdal spent weeks in a coma. Doctors did not expect him to survive.

Mirabdal did not die, but remains incapacitated, according to his father. Once a strapping football player at Moraga High School, the 24-year old no longer has use of his hands and cannot feed or dress himself. His nerves were severed in the assault and he suffers from excruciating nerve pain.

Despite his injuries, Mirabdal is a student at Diablo Valley College.

His father, Ali Mirabdal, runs a copy shop on Shattuck Avenue in North Berkeley. He said the assault has profoundly transformed his life. Mr. Mirabdal, who fled Iran when he was 17 because he disagreed with the country’s political direction, said the attack has made him less trusting.

“My whole family has been shattered by this,” said Mr. Mirabdal. “There is not a day I don’t break down and cry three or four times.”

Mr. Mirabdal thinks Flatbush and Mastro did not want to just rob his son, but kill him. He considers the assault a hate crime.

“They did it to him because they thought he was a Muslim,” he said.

If anyone has any information on the wallet, please email Sgt. Murphy at ejmurphy@ci.Berkeley.ca.us or call the Homicide Detail (510) 981-5741.

Tagged , , , ,
?
  • Jane Tierney

    San Lorenzo is a fairly short street. Someone should flyer the entire length with a notice, asking for help from the good Samaritan that returned the wallet.

    I had something similar happen in SF years ago. The father of the perp who mugged me returned my credit cards by slipping them inside the door of the bank at 6am. The security guard saw him and tried to reach him, but was too late. Later, the perp was found and convicted. I had to testify that he didn’t have my “permission” to use the cards.

    I hope they are able to reach a just conclusion on this one!

  • http://berkeleyhomes.com/blog Ira Serkes

    I’ve posted the link and post (I didn’t think BerkeleySide would mind in this case) in the Thousand Oaks Neighborhood ListServe.

    I also called the agent who’s name is on the note pad – she didn’t have any idea who it could be.

    If the first initial of the last name is M, it’s easy to do a tax record search of owner names on San Lorenzo and filter the leads.

    Ira

  • Frances Dinkelspiel

    Ira, I am impressed you found out who the agent was and called her. I could not decipher her name and am not sure if BPD did either. Everyone has offered good suggestions on how to track down the mysterious mailer Let’s hope the suggestions help the police figure this out.

  • Jane Tierney

    I placed several flyers on the poles along San Lorenzo and had another thought that prompted me to call the detective. He told me they canvassed door to door all along San Lorenzo and no one said they’d sent the note. Hope the person comes forward.

  • Ephemerol

    I feel reluctant to comment on this story as it’s too close to home for me as one who also survived a brutal attack in N. Berkeley years ago in the early ’90s and yet my life has been and is altered and changed in ways that have no name or description. Another part of me desires to help if only in some small ways. While this may sound critical in such a serious matter e.g. legal attempted murder, mayhem / hate crime and much worse. It does not sound like the local PD are not working this very hard on this or have little time do such. The persons initials are AM. I suspect that this person is also female and lives in the area or city if not that particular neighborhood. Try asking “each” and every resident if they hired or had a gardener working for them at any time. The note appears to written without hesitation and with spontaneity and was done by someone who has been educated in Americans schools as per the flow, cadence and content of the message or note. Someone in that neighborhood knows this person “if” the author is telling the truth about it’s location. Then there are DNA and enhanced finger print analysis and much more. If the letter was stamped or contained a stamp, there will be critical DNA under this stamp in conjunction with the glue, even if it’s self-adhering. This type of investigative finesse needs to be at the Federal level and not local nor farmed out.

    I personally am leaving Berkeley and will never ever return for a wide multitude of reasons and yes crime as well as incivility in all of it’s colors, are prime factors for this as well as this strange community denial of them.

    While that alone is “another” conversation for another time, I want to urge Mr. Mirabdal to seek out the best trauma therapists to help and assist him in not becoming a life long victim of this horrible tragedy. The California State Victims of Crime Program is hellish to deal with at best and most psychotherapists will not even talk to you on the phone or will make quick excuses i.e. “my schedule is full at this time”, or “I do not feel qualified to work with you etc.”, as per the cryptic, enigmatic and irrational State government “paperwork” involved, however you may not desire to be in therapy with such people anyhow. Let me suggest calling or bring up this organization for starters for leading edge trauma therapists in the area: http://www.emdr.com/ as well as view this video on the EMDR process and real trauma: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zBtqWrs2-K0&p=D31D0E6E42A441B6&playnext=1&index=28 Stay in the game of life and stay with the positive, go with the good, the beautiful and the life-enhancing forces everyday. And yes it’s not easy. Just stay on the path and fight to take back your life and your peace of mind.
    ______________________________________
    “Sometimes even to live is an act of courage.”

  • ruserious

    A couple of things that are being overlooked.

    Why would the person say “while gardening” ? Perhaps the person doesn’t live on San Lorenzo Ave, but is a gardener who WORKS on San Lorenzo Ave ? That would be a good reason to NOT put a return address (possibly in the U.S. illegally? )

    Secondly, has anybody checked the postmark on the envelope? Was it mailed from Berkeley?

  • Chris Iams

    I first heard about this horrible crime when NBC had a report about it the other night and their news van was parked at the W. end of San Lorenzo. [ I saw the story on t.v. and then looked out my front door and could see their news van.] I walked down and talked to the NBC crew. They had reported that Berkeley Police had said they knocked on all of our doors on San Lorenzo. I am home a lot of the time and no police have knocked on our door about this matter !!!!!!! I live on San Lorenzo.

    I do not think this serious crime is getting enough exposure. Could the Sgt. Murphy or other police really knock on our doors and leave copies of this article ???
    I will share this info. with my neighbors beside and across from me. I will try to tell more neighbors when time permits.

    Ira Serkes – - – If you read this could you copy this letter and give to all of us on San Lorenzo ? ? ? Checking that last initial on the note is a good idea – - – -you are certainly a computer wizard !

    I truly hope someone on our street can help solve this crime.

  • Pingback: Wallet sender comes forward in Berkeley crime case | Berkeleyside

  • Pingback: Berkeley has its own “Most Wanted” list | Berkeleyside