A Berkeley High star-turned-rapper takes tumble

Nathan Simmons, also known as Sliggitay, from his Facebook page

When Nathan Simmons graduated from Berkeley High School in 2003, he was lauded as an example of a student who seemed destined to go far.

Simmons had been a leader at Berkeley High. He played on the varsity basketball and tennis teams, took many AP classes, got mostly As, and served a semester as student body president. Half-white and half-black, Simmons had been selected by the administration to attend a conference in Cleveland Heights on the achievement gap, an appointment that garnered him mentions in the San Francisco Chronicle, the Daily Californian, and the Daily Planet.

And then there was his acceptance to Harvard.

“When I first got there I was on the Harvard trip — like, I’m gonna do this shit, I’m gonna get a great job, and I’m gonna be living my life,” Simmons told the East Bay Express in April. “Somewhere along the way, that changed.”

Simmons lasted about three years at the Ivy League institution, and in that time seemed to undergo a metamorphosis. Where he had once been the shining achiever, a large fish in a small pond, at Harvard he felt his urban roots keenly, according to what he told the Express. Instead of fitting in, he felt left out.

Simmons turned away from academics and towards another passion: music. He had become a rapper in high school, adopting the name Sliggitay (which means oral sex, according to the Urban Dictionary) and had his first hit while still in college, with a song that made fun of his black, upper class, third generation Harvard roommate. Then an arrest for drug possession (the charges were eventually dropped) and lewd public behavior hastened his exit from Harvard. He returned to the Bay Area and devoted himself to his music (while holding down a job in the molecular and cell biology department at Cal.)

His talent was noticed and he was mentioned along with other accomplished Berkeley rappers like Lil’ B and The Pack, The Cataracs, G-Eazy, Lyrics Born, YelaWolf, and others.

“Combining laid-back California drawl with the lightheartedness and soul of Southern rap, Slig is that rare artist that is equally enjoyable to listen to cruising through the town, sparking an L or at the club,” Andre David wrote on his blog, The Five and Dime Store. “Hailing from Berkeley, California, his rhymes have an unmistakable cadence and unique rhythm to them that separates him from the pack.”

By following more than 27,928 people on Twitter – and having an impressive 25,350 followers — and releasing his latest album, “The Mustache”, as a download in March, Simmons has continued to build on his music fame. (Even though the videos of his songs are so racy that they are not public.) Most of the songs “celebrate drug use and other vices in a not-very-subtle way,” according to the Express.

But, in late October, the rapper was arrested on charges of breaking into a home in San Francisco with the intent of raping a woman. Simmons, 26, who now lives in Piedmont, was arrested by police after allegedly breaking into a house in the south of Market area around 2:50 am on Oct. 30, according to police. A woman who was sleeping on a couch woke up to find a man standing over her, his pants down. The man pulled a blanket off the woman and she jumped up and screamed, prompting the man to run away.

The assailant had taken the woman’s iPhone and police were able to track it using GPS. They arrested Simmons in the 1600 block of Folsom Street.

Simmons has since pleaded not guilty to the charges and is being held on $1 million bail in San Francisco County jail, according to Bay City News.

His attorney, Charles Bourdon, declined to comment on the charges.

Print Friendly
Tagged , , , ,
  • Anonymous

    what is a “not intentional rapist”? maybe they can charge him with “non intentional rape”!!!

  • YouDontKnowAnything

    As history has well taught us, to be accused of something is not to have done it. As I know from working as a Public Defender, young black men in particular are a common target of false accusations and rushes to judgment (as displayed in this message board). Is it a crime, or is there something immoral about this individual’s artistic expression? The constitution values and protects that speech, and thankfully the individuals who fought for that right were much wiser than some of those posting comments here.

    Another thing I know from my work is that news reports more often than not have little to do with the facts of the case. This comment board is more of an embarrassment to Berkeley than Nathan Simmons has ever been. Save your judgments.

  • Dikelspiel_NotAJournalist

    Key Word: Accused. Stop reporting on “news” that is not even confirmed yet. Allegedly, Frances Dikelspiel never graduated from college. So let’s assume a million things about their character based on their past and what they think it means to be a “rapper”. Keep this bs editorial off-line.

  • you should all be ashamed

    As a close friend of Nathans and a Harvard classmate, I want to express my anger and sadness over this article and all the comments that have been written on the board.  Nathan is a kind, intelligent person, who is loved and admired by all who know him.  This “gangster” image the article mentioned was just that, an image.  The rapper persona he created was just a satirical take on hip hop culture today. Look at his videos and listen to his lyrics, he’s more of a dark and witty comedian than a “gangster” rapper.  

    More importantly, the problem with this article and all the comments is that you are all assuming Nathan’s guilt because of his arrest.  Mr. Dinkelspiel, I understand you are just doing your job as a reporter, but you need to realize what harm you have done by publishing this piece. You are tarnishing the reputation of a decent young man who hasn’t even had the chance to defend himself. As “youdontknowanything,” said this comment board is more of an embarrassment to Berkeley than Nathan has ever been. 

  • http://berkeley.accountableschools.com/ Berkeley Accountable Schools

    “Hella urban” is a quote from the Express article, which reads:

    “And, as a result, he always felt like an outsider in college. Moreover, he got the odd distinction of being “hella urban,” even in comparison to other African-American students. “My roommate was a black dude, but he was, like, third-generation Harvard legacy, like, rich-family private-school guy. He was startled by this dude from Berkeley who was, like, trying to drink forties and smoke blunts in the room and shit. He was bitching at me a lot.”

    “So the ex-high school president turned to music as a way to vent his frustration.”

    There are lots of colleges in the US: some are “party schools,” and some aren’t.  This guy went to the school that — more than any other — represents the “establishment” but was apparently unprepared or unwilling or both to adapt to (or at least accommodate) the norms of the institution.  I’m asking whether Berkeley could have given him some other choices.  So, I agree with you: it’s not surprising that the forties-and-blunts thing didn’t go over well in Cambridge.  But why is that acceptable here?

  • Bob

    As is Laura Menard.

  • Charles_Siegel

    “Is it a crime, or is there something immoral about this individual’s
    artistic expression? The constitution values and protects that speech”

    Free speech works both ways.  It gives rappers the right to their artistic expression.  It also gives us the right to criticize that artistic expression.  The constitution protects our speech as well as the rappers.

    I have trouble listening to rap, but the bit that I have forced myself to listen to is more thuggish, violent, obscene and angry obscene than any other music I have ever heard.  For all I know, there may be some rappers who are poets as sensitive as Wordsworth and Keats, but they are obviously the minority. I think the general criticisms of rap in this thread are justified – as are the worries that rap generally promotes a culture of violence and impulsiveness that makes it harder for high school students to succeed. 

    But I think most of the comments here are a criticism (or in some cases a
    defense) of rap and “hella urban” culture in general, and they do not
    necessarily apply to Simmons.  We should withhold judgment on Simmons until we know all the facts.  If he is vindicated at his trial, I will be happy to hear it.  I presume we will have more news about it.

  • Bruce Love

    I’m disappointed in you Charles.   Having admitted you’ve listened to very little, you nevertheless make sweeping generalizations about what it must be like. 

    I’ll tell you the real scourge.  It’s jazz.  It brings out base animal instincts.  It causes boys to become predatory and girls to become loose women.   Have you seen the way they dance?   And don’t let me take you down to the blues bar — you don’t want to hear the filth they’re singing.  And we know both of those worlds promote crime just by looking at the newspapers.

    Our guy Siggitay still has a few songs up on his MySpace page.  I recommend Baby Momma and J.A.P. for their humor and their twists on stereotypes.    The guy is a far more attuned and persuasive cultural critic than the anti-rap, anti-hip-hop, oh, let’s just say it, anti-Black-culture comments here.

  • BHS Graduate

    (it wouldn’t let me reply to your most recent comment, so I’m sticking it here)

    I’m in agreement he would have benefited from considering other options, or perhaps being presented with other options, however the notion that a party school would be the correct alternative is just what I’m trying to address. It’s not his blunt-smoking 40-pounding ways that define him as a human, but his identity (though clearly by his statements this behavior is part of that identity). It’s not necessarily as if he reeked of reefer in class and stank of booze in the deans office, more likely that he had a difficult time understanding these people and a harder time being motivated to impress them.

    There are plenty of institutions more open to a broad range of identity that aren’t party schools. There’s even one just up the street in UC Berkeley, which was ranked higher worldwide than Harvard in 2011 at #2. If he had gone to, say, Chico State or ASU he would have had plenty of opportunity to indulge in hedonistic behavior, but he would have felt the stagnation of his intellectual life.

    Mr. Simmons is not one half-drug addled rapist and one half academic wunderkind; he’s a whole man, and all of these elements are a part of him. As to why intoxication is acceptable in Berkeley: it’s not. Half the fun of skipping class to get stoned, at least in my time at BHS, was that we weren’t supposed to do it. It was taboo, and we were flexing our wings of independence. I respected those who knew how to get it, how to use it, and how to talk about it for that reason. These days, now that everyone knows how to get it how to use it and how to talk about it, and nobody cares if you use it, the allure simply isn’t there.

  • http://berkeley.accountableschools.com/ Berkeley Accountable Schools

    I have a different experience of the current situation, as I see BHS students lighting up in my neighborhood, during school hours.  I’ve also been asked to buy drugs in the park across the street from the school (and no, I don’t look 16 — just walking through).  So the allure is still there for some, but I take your point about the lure of forbidden fruit versus the commonplace.  

    I certainly agree with your major assertion — that people are composites of multiple selves, not all one thing or another.  My point wasn’t so much that he should have chosen a party school, but that he should have developed some other identities while in Berkeley.  The Express piece tells a story in which he had only two: high achiever and whatever you want to call the “hella urban” persona.  Some people can play the iconoclast and get away with it — Bill Gates and Mark Zuckerberg are famous examples of people who did that at Harvard and left, on their own terms.  (At least Zuckerberg left of his own choice; not sure about Gates).  When “high achiever” wasn’t enough, this guy played the only other card he seems to have known.  I wish Berkeley had dealt him a better hand.  

  • Anon

    totally agreed, wtf thats not a “tumble” thats an attempted rape!!!

  • Charles_Siegel

    I tried to listen, but it just keeps buffering forever and doesn’t play.  Maybe there is lots of demand because of his new notoriety.  

    I actually like blues and some jazz.  Cab Calloway is one of my favorites. 

    I shouldn’t have to point out the obvious flaw in your reasoning.  Fifty years ago, blues and jazz were criticized for moderate behavior, which everyone now accepts.  Therefore, you mistakenly imply, it it is wrong to criticize much more extreme behavior. 

    It is easy to keep repeating the “progressive” ideas of fifty years ago.  It is harder to come up with new ideas in response to new realities.

  • Bruce Love

    About “I shouldn’t have to point out the obvious flaw in your reasoning. 
    Fifty years ago, blues and jazz were criticized for moderate behavior,”

    Who is talking about 50 years ago?   I am talking about 70-90 years ago.

  • http://radar.oreilly.com/2007/09/local-recycle-reuse-hits-a-bur.html The Sharkey

    +10 points to Thomas Lord for his perfectly executed use of the Race Card!

    Someone should let Mr. Simmons know that rap is the exclusive property of African American culture and not actually a musical genre that is performed and enjoyed by persons of all ethnicities.

  • http://radar.oreilly.com/2007/09/local-recycle-reuse-hits-a-bur.html The Sharkey

    Don’t bother, Charles. When he descends into his Devil’s advocate pit of pedantry, trying to explain what you actually meant won’t ever work out in your favor.

  • stop blaming every one else

    Simmon’s arrest was covered in the major local papers weeks ago.

  • Heather W.

    Gotta say, I like both those tunes quite a bit, he’s got some biting social commentary in his work, and the other pieces I listened to were not classifiable as gangsta rap, either. So he’s a decent artist and some of it is thought provoking. From I’ve gathered about him from people who have known him, like most of us, he has a good and a bad side. One hopes that whatever the outcome of his current situation, something positive eventually comes about. 

  • Charles_Siegel

    Sharkey: He seems to be supporting me. 
    I said that he is repeating the “progressive” ideas of 50 years ago.
    He responded that he is repeating the “progressive” ideas of 70 to 90 years ago.

  • Bruce Love

    70-90 years ago jazz was criticized for male drunkenness, single mothers, suicides, the spread of marijuana, and so forth.  Indeed, public hype about the supposed base qualities of jazz was used to build public support for the prohibition of marijuana — which ironically today leads to some of the conditions to which some rap and hip-hop lyrics respond.

    In that same period, blues artists were singing celebrations of sex and violence in terms that would make many of today’s artists blush.

    The stakes were as extreme then as they are now and the idiocy that tries to pin social ills on genres of music was as stupid then as it is today.

  • ThisArticleIsMisleading

    I’m a friend. The fact is that nothing has necessarily gone wrong, this is still an allegation.

  • Anonymous

    His videos have all been marked “private” on YouTube.

  • Guest

    I don’t have any idea whether Nathan is guilty or innocent of the crime he has been accused of, but having grown up here and graduated from Berkeley High a little over 10 years ago I can share my experience regarding the interesting “mixing of social values and cultural norms promoted at BHS” mentioned earlier, especially since it seems like little has changed.  When I was at Berkeley High it was normal for the more privileged white/jewish/asian kids of North Berkeley/the hills to pick up “urban” mannerisms/lifestyles even as they excelled academically and went on to great Ivy league caliber universities.  A great example of this are Berkeley natives Andy Samberg and the Lonely Island, although in their case they seem to be well aware of the irony and use it as comedy fodder.  In the case of those who I have known though, hip hop dress, vernacular and overall mentality was something they took very seriously (and many still do, a decade or so later), despite the blatant inauthenticity of it all.  

    While I don’t have anything against hip hop culture, from what I’ve witnessed around me people who try to be something they are not end up stunting their own emotional and psychological development in the process of maintaining their inauthentic “urban” authenticity.  It’s almost like some strange privilege-guilt induced schizophrenia.

    Not sure how to relate all of this back to Nathan, but if there’s a lesson in all of this I think it would be that parents should instill in their kids a strong sense of self so that they are independently minded enough not to get sucked into this or that subculture.

  • Charles_Siegel

    I am sure that it is still as stupid as it was when those idiots Plato and Aristotle first made the point.

  • http://radar.oreilly.com/2007/09/local-recycle-reuse-hits-a-bur.html The Sharkey

    Charles, Tom is mocking you.

    He’s saying you’re as stupid now for criticizing gangsta rap as the people who were criticizing Jazz/Blues were 70-90 years ago.

  • Laura

    BL/TL

    name a Jazz artist shot by a rival Jazz player

  • Bruce Love

    From the era I was talking about:  James Reese Europe was stabbed to death by his drummer.   Or, you might ilke Chano Pozo who got killed in a fight with his marijuana dealer.  There are some pretty interesting lists of that kind of thing if you’re interested (just google).   Lots of early deaths from drug and drink — pretty wild crowd.

    You should probably expand your search, too, and think about violence that might be found in and around the jazz scene of those days.   Clubs in the shady parts of town.   Drug deals going wrong.   Romantic rivalries.  Crime boss rivalries.

    And if you wanna talk blues — now there was a violent and drug-addled bunch!

  • Laura

    Rap promotes violence, misogyny, and rivalry  far greater than any other art form, including the blues or jazz.

  • Laura

    There is a lot of truth in this comment, those you have not experience how the culture at BHS shapes identity should read this twice.

  • Lookingforfairness

    Do not write comments when you do not know the details of the case.  Once the facts come out, you are going to understand that what happened that particular night is one of those “nightmarish” incidents that we all can learn from, but there was not intent to rape (or rape) or to do any harm.  I hope you will be able to eventually learn the thruth and apologize.  Everyone in this country is inocent until proven guilty.  As far as I know, and I know, he is inocent.  Many of the comments make Nate sound like he is an addict and a terrible person, all very far from the truth.  He is now out of jail and trying to make sure his future choices do not allow him to put himself in this position again.  How unfortunate it is to see how fast we jump to conclusions and judgement without having any relevant information.  I guess I should not be surprised, there isn’t much kindness in humankind.

  • Joey

    Yelawolf is most certainly not from Berkeley.

  • NoeValleyJim

    So what finally happened to this guy? I see he is posting on Twitter again, so he must be out of jail. Was he ever convicted of anything?