Opinionator

Berkeley Iceland must be maintained, whatever its fate

By Tom Killilea

Tom Killilea is a long time Berkeley resident, internet technologist, and active in the Berkeley PTA. He is a cofounder and president of Save Berkeley Iceland.

Berkeley Iceland has been closed for over five years. For the majority of this time, the current owners, East Bay Iceland — EBI, Richard Zamboni, President — has allowed their historic property to be defaced, trash to collect on and around the building, and landscaping to become a receptacle of garbage. Complaints are ignored and the garbage keeps piling up, becoming an eyesore and potential hazard to the neighborhood.

A group of SBI volunteers, having seen enough of the total neglect, spent a recent Saturday morning cleaning the front the best they could without trespassing on the property.

The before and after pictures of the cleanup (above) show what even a small group can accomplish within the limited scope and with basic equipment.

It wouldn’t take much more to make significant improvements in the appearance of the building — some fresh paint to cover the worst of the tagging; bleach and power washer to clean up the terrazzo in the entry; more thorough efforts to trim and clean up the landscaping; elbow grease and paint remover to clean the doors.

SBI has made the offer in the past and it remains open: we will help organize efforts to maintain Berkeley Iceland in cooperation with the owners. This offer has been turned down in the past, sometimes with a temporary cleaning. Whether the owners choose to let us help or not, we are committed to maintaining the front of the building and will clean up trash on a periodic basis in the hope that the owners will commit to maintaing the rest of the site.

Based on history, this will not happen unless a lot of people make their voice heard. It is apparent that the owners believe that letting the appearance of Berkeley Iceland deteriorate will aid their efforts to get public approval for the proposal to turn Berkeley Iceland into a Sports Basement.

Almost everyone agrees that a big-box retail store in the Berkeley Iceland building is not a very desirable use, especially when the opportunity to return a public community ice rink was an active possibility. Cynically, the owners use the condition into which they have allowed the building to fall as an argument to first fight historical designations and now assist Sports Basement in their efforts to remove the possibility of an ice rink returning. They hope that the Berkeley community will accept a bad use as the only way to get the eyesore cleaned up.

East Bay Iceland has shown no respect for Berkeley and our City leaders have failed to defend our community. While it is understandable that EBI sees it in their interests for Berkeley Iceland’s appearance to degrade, why has the City of Berkeley taken no action against them? Where is the Mayor’s outrage over the out-of-town owners letting their property become a blighted mess? Why, in the five years of degradation, hasn’t the Council member for the neighborhood called for a cleanup or penalties against the owners for the eyesore his constituents have had to endure? Regardless of what use you want to see for Berkeley Iceland, there is no excuse to allow this to happen.

SBI calls on East Bay Iceland to clean up their historic property and on Berkeley leaders to speak up and take actions to make EBI clean up Berkeley Iceland. We stand ready to help and will continue to clean the front as best we can.

In six weeks our City leaders will be taking action to determine Berkeley Iceland’s future — the appeal of Sports Basement’s permits is on the agenda for the September 11 Council meeting. The condition that EBI has allowed Berkeley Iceland to fall is one indicator of why they took no consideration of the needs of Berkeley in their decision to promote the first big-box store in our community. The City Council should seriously include this as part of their decision.

Help us deliver this message to them by contacting your Berkeley elected official, and/or East Bay Iceland (Richard Zamboni, President, rzamboni@zamboni.com. And visit the City of Berkeley Public Works “Clean City” Program online.

Berkeleyside welcomes submissions of op-ed articles of 500 to 800 words. We ask that we are given first refusal to publish. Topics should be Berkeley-related and local authors are preferred. Please email submissions to us. Berkeleyside will publish op-ed pieces at its discretion.

Print Friendly
Tagged
  • Chris

    While I support SB going in there, it is pathetic that the owners cannot do basic maintenance on their property, and even more pathetic that the city hasn’t done anything about it.

  • bgal4

    The conditions around Iceland are so abhorrent that I called in a complaint this past week.

    Max Anderson ignores the blight because he prefers to use the mess as a rationale for pushing through the use permit for Sports Basement. He has publicly stated the only way to deal with the illegal dumping, litter, grafitti, and social disorder at this property is to pass the property over to a business.

    If this is the case than why has Anderson not succeeded in getting the owners of old King Liquors, the Toler family to develop the empty, blighted property going on 30 years of disrepair.  

  • Guest

    We have.neither the money nor the demand for a full time ice rink in the city of Berkeley.

  • 4Eenie

    I drove by while you guys were cleaning up last weekend. Thank you!

  • Chris

     Oh – this is in Max Anderson’s district? No wonder no one has done anything about the blight or garbage.

  • bgal4

     History shows that premise is inaccurate.

  • George

    As a West Berkeley resident, I also support Sports Basement moving into the Iceland location.  With just four locations all in the Bay area, and plans to reuse the existing structure, it is misleading to label this proposal as a “big box retail store.”  The company’s plans also provide lots of space for community events, and my Berkeley-based track club recently held our annual meeting at Sports Basement’s Walnut Creek location due to the support the company has shown for our local members.  The quickest way to get to site cleaned up is to move this project along, rather than appealing the permits to the City Council. 

  • David D.

    If there were demand for a full-time ice rink in Berkeley, Iceland wouldn’t have closed (or remained closed for so many years, anyway).

  • David D.

    SBI seems to suffer from the same ailment that afflicts many other older “progressive” Berkeleyans: NIMBYism masked as nostalgia. It’s great that you have fond memories of Iceland, but if the building is going to become a Sports Basement, what’s the problem? Let it be a Sports Basement. It’s not like we’re asking you to live with a Wal-Mart or something “offensive” like that! Plus any real progressive would let others live their lives as they see fit.

    As for the cleaning itself, thank you very much. I find it disrespectful and negligent of the property owner to fail to maintain his property. In fact, I hope the Berkeley City Council approves Sports Basement at its upcoming meeting with the requirement that, should Sports Basement ever leave the building, the owner be required to properly maintain his property. Failure to do so should result in fines, in addition to restitution to the city and/or whichever private company or volunteer organization is tasked with fixing the place up.

  • bgal4

    There are many reasons why business owners decide to close a business. Iceland drew skaters from many nearby cities. I used the rink lots, and it was always busy.
    So unless you have specifics I will trust the people I know who have knowledge of the various issues in the closure and sell by the Zamboni family.

  • David D.

    This is the same logic used by people who watch Fox News and think it’s accurate. Just sayin’. It might be hard to fathom, but if the ice rink were profitable, somebody would have reopened it by now–or opened an ice rink somewhere else in town.

  • The Sharkey

    I have to side with David on this one. I just don’t think a venture like this could be a private profitable enterprise, and I don’t think the City of Berkeley can afford to open another money pit right now.

  • bgal4

    Just sayin?? and then some absurd tangent to Fox news??

    Were either of you involved when the Zambino family decided they wanted out of the skating rink business?

    Because you might want to find out what the deal is before you quess.

  • Ice Fan

    Too bad one of the wealthy players on the San Jose Sharks or another NHL player who lives in the Bay Area couldn’t providing funding to restore the rink.  Or a locally-raised or locally-based figure skater, perhaps?  Or someone from Silicon Valley who made a fortune?  Wouldn’t it be a wonderful legacy to have kids learn to skate at the [ great hockey player / figure skater / tech star ] ice rink?

    Unfortunately, my Rolodex doesn’t contain any NHL players or figure skaters…

  • TN

    The Sharks are already affiliated with the Oakland Ice Center on 18 th Street.

    One of the reasons that a private investor might not find that reopening Iceland to pencil out is that there is another more modern ice rink fairly close by.

  • Gone

    Thanks for that remark, bgal4. Want to talk about eyesores? How about the burned-out building on the corner of Sacramento and Julia Streets that has been sitting there dragging down the entire neighborhood for 30 years? Berkeleyside, how about looking into the entire mess over there including the owners’ willful neglect of the property and the city’s tolerance of that blight?

  • The Sharkey

     There’s a bombed out building at the corner of Acton and Hearst that I drive by when I’m visiting divino that’s been an empty, decrepit mess for as long as I can remember. I’d love to know what’s up with that, too.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/N4S3WQDAJHAEYNLWRH34ZXUXKU Brian Y

    If I’m thinking of the same one (NW corner Acton & Hearst), I’m pretty sure I remember work actually being done on it perhaps three to three and a half years ago, and then stopping. I’ve always assumed they ran out of money or didn’t have all of their building permits lined up.

  • The Sharkey

    Sounds like the same one. They put some new double-paned windows in it, and then put tarps on top of the plywood and left it to rot.

    After a few years in the elements I don’t think any of it is salvageable, so at this point it probably ought to be torn down since it’s a fire hazard and an attractive nuisance.

  • PragmaticProgressive

    Let’s combine them:  an ice rink that is also a warm pool and a post office.

  • PragmaticProgressive

    Many professional athletes start out wealthy but don’t stay that way.  And I think NHL and figure skating contracts pay a lot less than MLB or the NFL.

    As for the investment side, as you probably know, the easiest way to make a million dollars is to start with two million dollars.

  • Anonymous

    Bravo.

  • Eileen Foran

    Iceswimailing… Perfect!

  • Lee Gogreen

    I go by that house also and wonder what the story about it is. I have friends who live directly across the street. If people ran out of money then the bank should sell that property so it can be rebuilt again.I Will contact Linda mail to get involved.

  • Mary

    I support Sports Basement. They have nice stores and offer lots of community events. They will attrack businesses to a less attractive part of shattuck AND keep that neighborhood and the new park cropping up next door, clean. No brainer for me. Welcome Sports Basement! Ignore the naysayers!

  • bgal4

    We got two news stories over many years written about the neighborhood efforts to work with the Toler family and the city to see progress on this blighted property which attracts crime and violence to our hood.

    Berkeley Daily Planet
    Chronicle

    We met for years with city staff, the Tolers, and merchants, nothing has changed. Waste of time.

    The latest effort is organized by the CalJulia group. California and Julia St group, I  read on their blog that the Tolers might be selling the property. The group was not interested in learning about the long list of previous efforts to solve this problem property, they chose to believe that their renewed positive approach might work better than 20 years of community efforts.

    Code enforcement in the last decade has refused to fine the Tolers for blight. 

  • 4Eenie

    Just walked past Iceland. I’m not sure what prompted it or who is responsible for getting something done after all this time, but all debris has been picked up on or near the premises. The grass has been cut on the berms. (Most of) the graffiti has been painted over. And the trash has been removed.

    Go see it while it’s clean! May not last long. It sure was a nice surprise!