Big Screen Berkeley: Oscar-nominated short subjects


HBO’s Prison Terminal: “I’d be shocked if it doesn’t win the Oscar Documentary prize,” says our film critic John Seal.

It’s time once again to handicap the Oscar races that most obsess Berkeleyside readers – I’m speaking, of course, of the short subjects. 2013’s crop of nominees is a strong one, and as in previous years will play as a package at Landmark’s Shattuck Cinemas beginning on Friday, Jan. 31.

Of the three categories, the Live Action group is (with one notable exception) particularly impressive. I’m picking former child actor Xavier Legrand’s Just Before Losing Everything – the riveting tale of a Frenchwoman (Lea Drucker) attempting to escape from her abusive husband – as the winner. Suspenseful and moving, the film suggests Legrand could easily transition to feature length productions should he so desire.

Likely runners-up include Denmark’s Helium, a touching blend of drama and fantasy about the brief happiness brought to a dying youngster by a hospital janitor, and The Voorman Problem, a mind-bender about a prisoner who insists he’s God – and proves it by making Belgium disappear. Finland’s Do I Have to Take Care of Everything?, a comedy about family misunderstandings, is genuinely funny but a bit too slight (and short) to take home the prize.

Bringing up the rear is That Wasn’t Me, a clumsy, ill-considered drama about the healing and redemptive effect middle-class white Europeans have on their little brown African brothers. I found the film repulsive and can’t imagine how or why it was nominated.

In most years Disney or Pixar productions dominate the Animation category, and that looks likely to continue in 2014. Disney’s Get A Horse!, a thoroughly charming tribute to the classic cartoons of the 1930s enlivened with an impressive infusion of modern 3D animation technology, is the deserving frontrunner. There’s stiff competition, however, in the form of Daniel Sousa and Dan Golden’s Wild Child-flavored Feral, a minimalist work with the look of an animated cave painting and a magnificent Popol-Vuh-style score, and Room on the Broom, a British production about a witch and her animal companions that will charm children of all ages. Featuring an impressive array of voice talent, including Simon Pegg, David Walliams, Sally Hawkins, Timothy Spall, and Gillian Anderson, it’s as warm and fuzzy as that chunky Christmas jumper your nan knitted for you.

Also nominated are Shuhei Morita’s bizarre Possessions, in which a Japanese wanderer takes shelter in a haunted storehouse filled with broken umbrellas, and Laurent Witz’s Mr. Hublot, a steampunk fantasy reminiscent of the works of Jean-Pierre Jeunet. I didn’t find either film particularly engaging, though they certainly look great.

I’ll be shocked if HBO’s Prison Terminal (scheduled to debut on the network on March 31) doesn’t win the Documentary prize: unflinchingly recording the final days of decorated World War II veteran Jack Hall, a convicted murderer dying in a prison hospice, it’s an utterly unsentimental yet deeply affecting little masterpiece. I can’t imagine a more powerful piece of film-making – bring an extra hanky.

There are several other worthy contenders in the category, including Karama Has No Walls, an astonishing compilation of footage shot in the Yemeni city of Sana’a at the height of the Arab Spring; Facing Fear, a truth is stranger than fiction examination (by the Bay Area’s Jason Cohen) of two very different Californians and the paths that led them to meet twice in unusual circumstances; and The Lady In Number 6, an elegiac biography of the world’s oldest Holocaust survivor, a 110-year old Czech woman who plays the piano every day in her London flat.

Finally, Jeffrey Karoff’s Cave Digger takes a look at a New Mexico man who…wait for it…digs caves. The film bored me to tears, which – considering the subject matter – is perhaps appropriate.

Berkeleyside’s film writer John Seal writes a weekly movie recommendation column at Box Office Prophets, as well as a column in The Phantom of the Movies’ Videoscope, an old-fashioned paper magazine, published quarterly. 

To find out about more events in Berkeley and nearby, visit Berkeleyside’s Events Calendar. We also encourage you to submit your own events.

Print Friendly
Tagged , , , , ,
Please keep our community civil. Comments should remain on topic and be respectful.
Read our full comments policy »
  • Robbiesfo

    Curious . . . did the author actually view all these films?

    I saw Berkeley’s Jason Cohen’s production of “Facing Fear” at the Mill Valley Film Festival. While certainly opinions and tastes can differ, I find the description way off the mark.

    It would be a shame for people who’ve read this article to have the impression that the film is about something as curious and quirky as two people’s paths crossing. The story of the film is so much deeper, more meaningful, and powerful than that. Indeed, if anything, is qualifies as a “deeply affecting little masterpiece.” I can’t provide a better description than the trailer:

    I would encourage all interested to see it when the group of films make their way to the Landmark’s schedule. The story is remarkable and is enhanced by the highly skilled filmmaking and production.

    BTW, according to Landmark’s website, it looks like the documentary shorts are not playing at Shattuck, but only in SF at Opera Plaza in February.

  • spenc

    I too am shocked that Berkeley’s own Jason Cohen did not get paid more attention in this article. His film “Facing Fear” is an absolute masterpiece. You are doing the folks of Berkeley a real disservice by not reporting more fully on this film.

  • TheRealJohnSeal

    Robbie, it seems to be a common misconception that people who write about film don’t watch the films they review! For the record, I watch all the films I review and spent most of last weekend screening the short subjects.

    I agree that Facing Fear is a fine film: that’s why I described it as a ‘worthy contender’. If Prison Terminal weren’t nominated, I’d probably consider it the favorite, but Prison Terminal WAS nominated, and in my opinion stands head and shoulders above the competition. That’s no knock on Facing Fear, which I recommend unreservedly.

    It’s incredibly unfortunate that the documentaries won’t be opening this weekend in Berkeley. Thanks for catching that.

  • Robbiesfo

    I’m glad to hear you saw the films. My comment, which began with a question, was based on your description of Facing Fear. As I noted, tastes and opinions can differ. I was, and am, more concerned with the characterization of the film and what impression it leaves with the reader — in my opinion it was undeserved and gave rise to the original question.

  • Watch this space spenc! We have a whole feature on Jason and his documentary which will be published on Berkeleyside very soon!