Counting crows: Why are there so many in Berkeley?

Crows staging in a tree after sunset. Photo: Elaine Miller Bond
Crows staging in a tree after sunset, Alfred Hitchcock-style: their numbers have increased significantly in the Bay Area. Photo: Elaine Miller Bond

“Why are there so many darn crows in Berkeley these days?”

We get that question a lot at Berkeleyside, and Golden Gate Audubon gets it too.

It’s not just Berkeley. Crows are on the increase throughout the Bay Area, as are their larger and deeper-voiced cousins, ravens.

Back in the 1980s, Golden Gate Audubon members typically found between 30 and 90 American Crows each year in our Oakland Christmas Bird Count, which includes Berkeley. We typically found fewer than ten Common Ravens.


Since 2010, however, the count has turned up over 1,100 crows and 170 to 300 ravens each year.

A pair of crows before sunset on a telephone wire. Photo: Elaine Miller Bond
A pair of crows before sunset on a telephone wire. Photo: Elaine Miller Bond

“Crows have gone from being very uncommon to common to abundant,” said Rusty Scalf,  a Golden Gate Audubon birding instructor who lives in Berkeley. “Ravens used to be unheard of in the city, but now they’re all over the place.

If you’ve seen hundreds of crows flapping and cawing in a single tree — a murder of crows in fact — you might think that 1,100 crows is an understatement, and Berkeley is on the verge of being taken over à la Hitchcock by these bold, loud creatures. You might join the many bird lovers who accuse crows of driving down local songbird populations by stealing and eating their eggs.

But on both these counts, crows get a bum rap. The real crow story is more complicated.

Crows are intensely social and intelligent birds that, like humans, maintain both a family life and a community life.

During breeding season – spring and summer – they spend time with their family, building a nest and raising young on a defined territory. Adult crows usually mate for life. Juvenile crows stick around for several years and help their parents feed the nestlings. (Don’t you wish your teenagers would do that?)

A raven: the larger, deeper voiced cousin of the crow, also on the increase locally. Photo: Elaine Miller Bond
A raven: the larger, deeper voiced cousin of the crow, also on the increase locally. Photo: Elaine Miller Bond

In the winter, on the other hand, crows often come together for the night in huge colonies. Around sunset, they gather at a staging area such as a big tree, calling and flapping and chasing each other. Then they fly together to another tree to roost for the night.

If you’ve had one of those jaw-dropping “is this Hitchcock?” moments, you may have been glimpsing one of these winter evening roosts. But if you think 50 or 100 birds in one tree is a lot, consider this: Auburn, New York had groups of 25,000 crows in a single roost as far back as the 1930s.

And Fort Cobb, Oklahoma, had one crow roost in 1972 with more than 2 million birds – enough to rival the Passenger Pigeon flocks that used to darken midwestern skies before they went extinct a century ago.

“They do a lot of chasing and calling and preening in these groups, the function of which is not readily apparent,” said Kevin McGowan, a crow expert at the Cornell Laboratory of Ornithology. “I think of them potentially as singles bars, crows going in and trying to find a mate.”

According to McGowan, crows’ negative reputation as nest predators is largely undeserved.

Yes, crows do feed on songbird eggs. But studies have shown that crows play a relatively small role in nest predation.

“There are studies that put cameras into nests and watch for predators,” McGowan said.  “The main nest predator is almost always squirrels and snakes. Then come mammals like raccoons and possums, then jays, raptors, cowbirds and mice. Crows are way down on the list.”

According to McGowan, the spread of crows and ravens into urban areas like Berkeley probably has a variety of roots:

  • Crows happily devour many kinds of human debris, such as French fries and other fast food scraps.
  • Their main predator, the Great Horned Owl, is relatively scarce in cities. Plus city street lights help crows spot and evade owls at night.
  • Cities tend to be 5 to 10 degrees warmer than the surrounding countryside since sidewalks and buildings absorb heat. That’s a boon for birds in winter.
A raven in a tree. Photo: Elaine Miller Bond
A raven in a tree. Photo: Elaine Miller Bond

On top of this, crows and ravens were added in 1972 to the list of species protected under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act of 1918. That meant farmers could no longer shoot them as pests – and so the birds gradually learned to be less leery of people.

And while West Nile virus took a heavy toll on crow populations back east over the past 15 years, it doesn’t seem to have significantly hit Bay Area birds.

Crows’ and ravens’ adaptability has been aided by the fact that they are some of the smartest birds around. Crows recognize individual human faces, and will respond with hostility to someone who has threatened their nest on past occasions. They make and use tools – for instance, pulling off a sliver of wood to poke a yummy spider out of a crevice.

(And don’t forget that viral YouTube video of a Russian crow making a plastic lid into a rooftop sled. Although, really, couldn’t the crow just be trying to peck crumbs from the lid and sliding by accident?)

Right now, we’re entering the start of nesting season. So for the next few months, you’ll be less likely to see giant crow gatherings in large trees at dusk. Instead, you may find a group of five or six crows hanging out in your yard. John Marzluff, a crow researcher at the University of Washington, found that suburban nesting pairs tend to defend territory stretching across two backyards – that’s one crow family for every other house.

Don’t want crows in your yard?  You can try banging pots to scare them away, but you’ll need to do this consistently. And it’s probably not worth making a scarecrow: Crows are too smart to be deceived for more than a day or so.

“The best thing is to change your attitude,” McGowan said. “Those crows in your yard aren’t a mob. They’re not a gang. They’re probably a family. And they’re very beautiful if you look at them.”

Some Corvid facts:

Crows and ravens are members of the corvid family, along with jays and magpies. Our local species are American Crows and Common Ravens.

Ravens are larger than crows, but that won’t help you identify them unless a crow has helpfully chosen to sit right next to a raven. Instead, look for the larger, heavier beak on the raven and the shaggy “beard” of feathers on its throat. The raven’s voice is deep and croaky, while the crow has a higher-pitched caw. In flight, a crow’s tail has a flat or slightly rounded end while a raven’s tail ends with a v-shaped wedge.   Easy memory aid: Raven is spelled with a “v,” and has a v-shaped tail. 

A crow comes in to land on a roof. Photo: Elaine Miller Bond
A crow comes in to land on a roof. Photo: Elaine Miller Bond

Learn more:

Learn about Bay Area birds: come on one of Golden Gate Audubon’s free bird walks.

Ilana DeBare is Communications Director for Golden Gate Audubon Society, where she edits the blog Golden Gate Birder. She is working on a novel.

Elaine Miller Bond is the author/illustrator of Affimals: Affirmations + Animals and the newly published Dream Affimals, from Sunstone Press. She is also the photographer for the upcoming book, The Utah Prairie Dog.

Read more about wildlife in Berkeley on Berkeleyside.

Related:
Darlings not Draculas: The bats that live in Berkeley (12.23.13)
In a Berkeley park a bluebird displays unusual behavior
 (08.05.13)
Lynxes of the bird world: Cooper’s hawks nest in Berkeley (04.18.13)
The mystery and thrill: Shorebirds enjoy winter in Berkeley (03.21.13)
Sitting on the dock of the bay: Birds throng Berkeley pier 02.28.13)
Rare bluebird sightings bring happiness in a Berkeley park (08.07.12)
In Tilden Park’s Jewel Lake: Spotting a rare river otter (04.05.12)
Up close with Berkeley’s wildlife at Tilden Regional Park (03.06.12)

Do you rely on Berkeleyside for your local news? You can support us by becoming a Berkeleyside Member. Choose either a monthly payment or a one-time contribution. Help make your independent local news source sustainable for the long term.