Schools

School board votes on short-term overcrowding solutions

Students and faculty from Berkeley Adult School stand and hold signs in solidarity against relocation of the school on Thursday's board meeting. Photo: Seung Y. Lee
Students and faculty from Berkeley Adult School stand and hold signs in solidarity against relocation of the school at Wednesday’s board meeting. Photo: Seung Y. Lee

The Berkeley School Board voted unanimously Wednesday on a two-year stop-gap solution to handle overcrowding in schools in the coming years.

Although the discussion for the long-term solution, which involves replacing the Berkeley Adult School with an elementary school, was not discussed by the Board, the issue drew over 200 people, including over 100 BAS students and faculty members holding signs in solidarity.

Read more about school enrollment issues on Berkeleyside.

Over 20 Berkeley residents and students spoke during the public comments, providing a wide spectrum of opinions in support and against the BAS relocation proposal. Board president Judy Appel announced there will be a town hall meeting on February to allow more people to speak.


“We’re not in a position to talk about the long-term solutions,” said Superintendent Donald Evans. 

Some of the 100 supporters of the Berkeley Adult School at the board meeting. Photo: Seung Y. Lee
Some of the more than 100 supporters of the Berkeley Adult School at the board meeting. Photo: Seung Y. Lee

The solution was split into short-term (the 2015-16 school year) and medium-term (2016-17 school year). The Board decided on what flex spaces would be converted to classrooms and consolidating Transitional Kindergarten (TK) classes to a new site for the former, and on how many portables would be installed for the latter.

Following board member Josh Daniels’ revised short-term proposal, flex rooms in Jefferson and Rosa Parks elementary schools would respectively be the first rooms used to accommodate the surplus of students. If enrollment projections call for three to five new classes, three TK sections at the King Child Development Center would be first consolidated to make space, followed by Jefferson and Rosa Parks.

The Board did not make a decision on what may happen if projections call for more than five classes, as it could not decide whether a flex space in John Muir or Emerson elementary schools would be the next in line.

It deferred to asking for a staff recommendation on what spaces would be prioritized if projections called for six to eight classes. The Board agreed to discuss it in the next meeting on Feb. 10.


For the 2016-17 school year, the Board voted on having three portables at both Thousand Oaks Elementary and LeConte Elementary and one portable at John Muir Elementary. While concerns for lack of space at John Muir were raised by Evans, the Board approved with the clarification that the portables issue will be revisited for revision in the next 18 months.

“It’s alway easier practically and politically to pull back than to expand later,” said Daniels, who proposed including a portable in John Muir in the plan.

Despite coming to consensus on how to solve the overcrowding issue for the next two school years, the long-term future remained contentious. The long-term solution has been narrowed down to two choices: developing a new elementary school on the Berkeley Adult School’s current site at 1701 San Pablo Ave. or at 1723 Oregon St., currently a maintenance facility.

The 1723 Oregon St. project would require more time and money to develop into a school than the BAS site. The former is projected to take about five years to develop and $20-25 million, according to a presentation from Asst. Superintendent Pasquale Scuderi.

The BAS site could be opened as soon as the 2017-18 school year and will cost a fraction of the Oregon Street project at between $2-3 million.


During public comments, student parents said that the Board has a responsibility to serve K-12 education first and that the BAS site was the more practical solution.

“I submit the only place available within the next three years in the Adult School,” said Joshua Room, a parent. “I think the board has a mandate to primarily serve K-12 but in doing so it must cushion the damage this change might incur.”

Parents from Emerson Elementary expressed concern about the possible loss of flex space. Photo: Seung Y. Lee
Parents from Emerson Elementary expressed concern about the possible loss of flex space. Photo: Seung Y. Lee

Several teachers, especially those who teach in the flex rooms that are in jeopardy, spoke of the impact it will have on themselves and the students.

“Room 11 is used to its best advantage,” said Lucy Ames, an art teacher at Emerson. “We’re stretched really thin. I really hope that you’ll consider other options.”

BAS supporters pushed back, saying adult education is as important as K-12 education, especially for first-generation immigrants who do not speak fluent English and lack the technical skills to find a job in the United States.

“Just as you wouldn’t considering eliminating the high school side, why would you eliminate the BAS side?” said Joyce Harrison, an ESL teacher at BAS. “We as educators have responsibility to provide for all.”

Former students told their experiences on how BAS opened new paths to community colleges and further educational developments.

“It was because of BAS that I was able to transition to college,” said Tangela Griffin, a former BAS valedictorian and student at Berkeley City College. “If this college is relocated, it would displace hundreds of people who are trying to be active members of society. I’m living proof that Berkeley Adult School works.”

Seung Y. Lee is a journalist who has previously worked at the Los Angeles Times, San Francisco Chronicle and the Daily Californian. Read more Berkeleyside coverage related to Berkeley schools.

Related:
Berkeley School Board primer: Decision time for board on overcrowding (01.14.15)
Berkeley School Board primer: Discussion of overcrowding solutions continues (12.10.14)
School board considers options for tackling student surge (11.13.14)

Get the latest Berkeley news in your inbox with Berkeleyside’s free Daily Briefing. And make sure to bookmark Berkeleyside’s pages on Facebook and Twitter. You don’t need an account on those sites to view important information.