The man also followed women in several other cities, police said. He is no longer in custody and police are seeking additional witnesses.
The city says the process will focus on finding diverse candidates and that it will involve robust community engagement.
One parent who witnessed the incident told police it was “super disturbing” and that Herbert Blue’s behavior was sexually motivated.
Police said David Godwin had a knife and a “large wad of cash in his hands” when he was arrested.
“We must employ a variety of tactics to deter, intervene and investigate crimes,” West Berkeley Councilmember Terry Taplin said during Wednesday’s Zoom.
“Our community needs to be made aware,” said a cyclist who asked to remain anonymous because the investigation is underway.
Police say the man enticed the teenager with marijuana and offered him a ride home, then locked the doors, drove him around and ultimately sodomized him.
Berkeley Police Chief Jen Louis said detectives have “some very promising investigative leads” and that she’s put extra officers on patrol.
Police said the 19-year-old harassed his ex-girlfriend with texts that became “threatening and aggressive” and fired a “warning shot” outside her home.
Police identified Jose Paz-Leja as a convicted felon and “documented West Side Berkeley” gang member who has other gunfire arrests in the neighborhood.
The driver may have lost control and struck a fence, trapping the man under her white Toyota sedan, first responders said over the radio.
Officer Cheri Miller committed no crime but she did violate city policy, according to the police investigation, and ultimately lost her job.